Laws of mathematics don’t apply to Australia: Malcolm Turnbull

16 July 2017 12:40 pm

The laws of mathematics state there are problems breaking end to end encryption. As Pursuit points out, modern encryption uses maths.

How so? Well, there’s an algorithm on your computer that transforms your message into a sequence of ones and zeros that’s meaningless except to a reader who knows the secret key that can transform it back, or decrypt it. The best-known encryption algorithm is RSA. It works on the most basic mathematical foundation - the fact that it’s easy to multiply but hard to factorise. To generate an RSA key you choose two random, very large prime numbers (hundreds of digits long), then you multiply them together and publish the result. You keep the prime factors secret - this is your decryption key. If you choose large enough primes, it’s just too hard to run enough computation to extract them and decrypt your message.

Malcolm Turnbull however sees it differently.

On Friday, the government unveiled plans to introduce legislation this year forcing internet companies to assist law enforcement in decrypting messages sent with end-to-end encryption.

The package will also contain authority for the Australian Federal Police to "remotely monitor computer networks and devices", a power currently possessed by the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation, and force handset makers to help authorities break into devices they sell.

"The laws of Australia prevail in Australia, I can assure you of that," Malcolm Turbull said on Friday. "The laws of mathematics are very commendable, but the only law that applies in Australia is the law of Australia."

The Prime Minister’s lack of insight into the laws of mathematics stunned the experts.

“What he seems to be saying is he wants access to messaging systems that are end-to-end encrypted,” Dr Vanessa Teague, from Melbourne University's School of Computing and Information Systems told HuffPost Australia.

"The mathematical opportunity to do that is not available."

Then again, the Turnbull government’s #waronmaths makes sense,

Take a look at the way the government slashed university funding in the Budget.

And the Prime Minister is absolutely correct in saying the laws of mathematics don’t apply to Australia. Take a look at his budget.

And take a look at the way gross govt debt is now at $504.679 billion. That’s up more than $226 billion since the 2013 election.

Yep, the Turnbull government's war on science and mathematics makes sense.



22 Oct 2017 - Trump vow to declassify Kennedy files is a distraction

07 Oct 2017 - What’s ahead for the Minerals Council of Australia?


16 Sep 2017 - Australia’s energy crisis shows the stupidity of privatisation

09 Sep 2017 - Why climate change will devastate Florida


16 Jul 2017 - Laws of mathematics don’t apply to Australia: Malcolm Turnbull


17 Jun 2017 - Political backlash over the Grenfell fire

11 Jun 2017 - A win for Macron is a lesson for Theresa May

04 Jun 2017 - Attacks in London could change the election


28 May 2017 - Why Donald Trump will survive and be re-elected in 2020

20 May 2017 - Will the Mueller probe examine Trump’s Russian business ties?

13 May 2017 - Hypocrisy over Chloe Shorten’s necklace

06 May 2017 - Macron vs Le Pen: France is no longer one country


29 Apr 2017 - Turnbull government attacks banks over Adani

23 Apr 2017 - Why the French election is important

08 Apr 2017 - Russian navy moves in

01 Apr 2017 - Australia is one of the world’s worst money laundering property markets


19 Mar 2017 - Peter Dutton goes poofter bashing

04 Mar 2017 - Trump will take the market to a fiscal bloodbath


26 Feb 2017 - Trump’s mental condition

18 Feb 2017 - Adani’s results tell us the company will not develop in Australia

11 Feb 2017 - Why the Coalition’s “clean coal” plan is crap

04 Feb 2017 - It’s Trump versus the courts


27 Jan 2017 - The cost of Trump's wall on consumers

21 Jan 2017 - A look at Europe's future

20 Jan 2017 - Can Trump make America great again?

16 Jan 2017 - Trump parallels with Iraq

View archive